February 16, 2015
Siegal, a New York City television journalist, kicks off the Emma on the Air series by introducing Emma Perez, a half-Dominican eight-year-old who decides that becoming a reporter on TV is just the ticket to becoming famous. “I knew TV reporters were special,” think Emma, “and that’s what I wanted most. To be special.” Emma just needs a good story to jumpstart her career, and she finds it when someone sneaks a worm into a lonely classmate’s burger. Readers may solve this small mystery before Emma does, but it’s clear that Siegal’s heroine has all the personality and persistence necessary for a career in front of a camera (or between the pages of a chapter book). Ages 7–10.
February 1, 2015
Gr 2-4-This series opener introduces eight-year-old Emma, resident of Washington Heights, NY. Her most memorable trait, besides her Hispanic heritage, which comes up often in the book-especially when she speaks in short Spanish phrases-is her great desire to be famous. She mentions it often, sings it, and chants it. It is the driving force behind the plot of the book, in which Emma learns how to be a TV reporter and starts an investigation of how a worm gets into a burger in the school cafeteria. The adults, including her father and her teachers, seem irritated by her need to be famous, and it has a similar effect on readers. Emma is an intelligent girl who learns real skills and takes initiative toward a goal, but it is all overshadowed by her annoying personality and relentless quest for fame. The writing, also, contains too much exposition and not enough description. There are too many exclamations, too many explanations, and not nearly enough character development. The design and illustrations will appeal to children, especially the large eyes and the bright cover, and the book is formatted and designed well. VERDICT Despite a good subject and plotline, the character of Emma is just too cloying to embrace.-Shalini Miskelly, St. Benedict Catholic School, Seattle, WA
Copyright 2015 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
July 1, 2015
Eight-year-old Emma Perez wants to be a TV reporter. Bursting with confidence, tenacity, and boundless energy, and mentored by her newspaper journalist father, she lands her first big story when a classmate finds a worm in his lunch. Emma's character is borderline twee, but her half-Dominican heritage and bilingualism are seamlessly integrated into the text. Frequent illustrations enhance the chapters.
(Copyright 2015 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)